A Mortgage Broker Answers Your Home Buying Questions
A conversation with Boris Cherner, MBA, Senior Mortgage Banker
Buying a home has come up in a lot of my planning conversations lately. Some people are tired of renting. Some have a growing family and a shrinking apartment. Some are parents whose grown kid is ready to buy and wants to know how to help.
Almost every one of those conversations runs into the same two walls: there isn't much on the market, and borrowing costs more than it did a few years ago. I can't do anything about inventory or rates. What I can do is help people go into the process knowing what they're signing up for.
For that I wanted a lender's view, so I asked Boris Cherner, MBA a few questions. Boris is a mortgage broker who ran his own mortgage shop before 2008, and he came out of that period with one rule that shapes everything he does. His answers are below, in his own words. They cover family help with the down payment, co-signing, co-ops, physician loans, the gap between a pre-approval and a budget, and the one part of a Loan Estimate almost everyone skips.
You ran your own mortgage shop before 2008. What did that period teach you that still shapes how you work today?
That getting approved and being able to afford the house are two different things. Before 2008 the industry made loans to anyone who could qualify on paper, and sometimes not even that. A lot of those people lost their homes.
I came out of it with one rule. My job isn't to close a loan. It's to make sure the person is still happy in that house five years later. So I start with the budget, not the approval, and I ask the uncomfortable questions up front. If the numbers don't work, I say so.
When a grown kid wants to buy, parents are often the first call. What's the most common way parents help, and what does a lender actually need to see?
Most often it's a gift toward the down payment or closing costs. Co-signing comes up too, but a gift is the simplest.
For a gift I need three things:
A signed gift letter stating the amount, the relationship, and that the money doesn't have to be repaid.
A paper trail showing the money leaving the parent's account and landing in the buyer's account or with the title company.
A statement from the parent's account showing the funds were there.
The best advice I can give: call the lender before anyone moves money. A large deposit that shows up with no explanation creates more questions than the gift itself.
Is there a real difference between gifting a kid money for a down payment and lending it to them, as far as the lender is concerned?
Yes, a big one. A gift is not a debt. It doesn't add a payment, and it doesn't count against the buyer when I calculate what they qualify for.
A loan is a debt. The payment counts in the buyer's debt-to-income ratio, and on most loan programs borrowed money that isn't secured by an asset can't be used for the down payment at all.
What parents can't do is call it a gift on paper and expect to be repaid. The gift letter says no repayment, and everyone signs it. Larger gifts may also mean a gift tax filing, usually with no tax owed, so that part is worth a conversation with your CPA or planner.
What are parents really signing up for when they co-sign?
The whole loan, not a backup role. A co-signer is a borrower. If a child misses a payment, the lender expects it from the parents, and the late payment will damage their credit scores too.
A few things parents don't always expect:
The full mortgage shows on their credit report and counts against them when they apply for their own financing.
I underwrite them like any borrower: income, assets, debts, tax returns.
There's no simple way off the loan later. Getting a parent removed usually means the kid refinances alone or sells.
Co-signing can be the right move. I just want parents to go in knowing it's a long commitment, with a plan for when and how they come off.
So many first homes in New York are co-ops. How does that change the picture compared to buying a house?
With a co-op you're not buying real estate. You're buying shares in a corporation that owns the building, plus a lease on your unit. That changes almost everything.
The board has to approve you, and boards set their own rules. Many want 20% or more down and money left in the bank after closing, no matter what a lender would accept.
The building's finances matter as much as yours. Its underlying mortgage, its reserves and how many units are owner-occupied all affect whether a lender will finance a unit there.
The monthly maintenance covers the building's property taxes and its mortgage, so compare total monthly cost, not just the purchase price.
Fewer lenders make co-op loans, and the process is typically more complex and takes longer.
For the record, I don't lend on co-ops. I did one early in my career and decided to leave them to people who do them every day. If you're buying one in New York, work with a lender and an attorney who specialize in them.
Physician loans come up a lot with young doctors. Who are they genuinely good for, and when are they the wrong tool?
A physician loan lets a doctor buy with little or nothing down and no mortgage insurance, and it's more forgiving about student loans. Some will also let you close before your first day, based on a signed employment contract.
It fits a doctor who has the income, or is about to, but hasn't had time to save: a new attending, or a fellow who knows where they're staying. It also helps if you have the down payment but would rather keep that cash in reserve.
It's the wrong tool when:
You have 20% down and a conventional loan comes out cheaper.
You'll likely move in two or three years. With nothing down you have no equity, and buying and selling costs money.
You're using it to buy more house than your budget supports. A bigger approval isn't a reason to spend it.
Say someone gets pre-approved for $900K. How do you talk them through the gap between what the bank will lend and what they should spend?
This is the qualification vs affordability part of homebuying that I address with every client before the pre-approval, not after. The $900K is math on your gross income and your debts. It doesn't know your future plans, what you spend on childcare, what you put into retirement, or that you like to travel.
So we build a budget first. What comes in, what goes out, what you're saving, and what monthly housing payment leaves room for the rest of your life. Then we work backward from that payment to a price. Sometimes it's $900K. Often it's less.
I tell people to buy a home they can afford to enjoy. If the payment means no vacations and no cushion, the house isn't a win, even if the bank says yes.
What's one thing on a Loan Estimate people almost always skip that they shouldn't?
Section A on page 2, Origination Charges. People go straight to the rate and the "Total Closing Costs" line and skip the one section that belongs entirely to the lender.
That's where points are. A lender can advertise a lower rate by charging points up front, and unless you look at Section A you won't see that there is a charge for it. When you compare two estimates, put the rate and Section A side by side, then check the "In 5 Years" line on page 3. It shows what you'll have paid and how much principal you'll have paid off, which tells you whether those points were worth it.
A few other things about the form that trip people up:
"Total Closing Costs" isn't just closing costs. It includes prepaids: your first year of homeowners insurance, the money to set up your escrow account, and interest from your closing date to the end of the month. That's your money going into your own accounts, not a fee.
Many of the costs on the form have nothing to do with the lender. Title charges and state, city or county transfer taxes are the same no matter who you borrow from.
Everything outside Section A is an estimate at the initial stage. The numbers move once the actual insurance quote, property taxes and escrow analysis come in. Section A is the part the lender controls, so that's the part to compare.
When do you tell someone not to buy?
More often than people expect. The usual reasons:
Closing would empty your savings. If the water heater dies in month two, you need money left.
The payment only works if nothing changes. One income dips or daycare starts, and it falls apart.
You don't know if you'll be there in three to five years. Buying and selling both cost money, and it takes time to make that back.
You're buying because someone told you rent is throwing money away. It isn't. Sometimes renting is the smart move.
"Not now" isn't the end of the conversation. We put together a plan: what to pay down, how much to save, what to fix on credit. I'd rather wait a year for a client than put them in a house that hurts them.
Where planning and lending meet
The line I keep coming back to is Boris's "buy a home you can afford to enjoy." A pre-approval tells you what a bank is willing to lend. It can't tell you whether the payment leaves room for retirement savings, childcare, a trip, and a cushion for that water heater. That part is a planning question, and it's best answered before the house hunt starts.
Boris Cherner, MBA is a Senior Mortgage Banker NMLS #1579104 with Capital Bank. He is not affiliated with FAR Financial, and neither party is compensated for referrals. His answers reflect his own views and experience. This post is for educational purposes only and is not individualized financial, tax, legal, or lending advice. Loan programs, requirements, and terms vary by lender and change over time.
The information shared in this article is intended only to provide general financial education, for informational purposes only. The information and opinions within should not be regarded as objective facts. The publisher cannot guarantee that content is accurate and updated to reflect changes in legislation, financial data, or opinion.
This content does not provide financial, tax, legal, or any professional advice. Personal financial decisions should not be implemented based on the content of this site. Do not act upon any information without first consulting a licensed investment, tax, or legal professional.
Igor Aronov, the publisher of this content, is a registered investment adviser representative and owner of FAR Financial Inc.